are stalemate starts a blight on roller derby?


At one point in the Nightmare on 95 East Regionals roller derby championship game on Sunday, I watched the eventually victorious Gotham Girls forcing the Philly Roller Girls to essentially spend around a minute — which felt like hours — trying to figure out how to move a starting pack that was standing around preventing the jammers from getting anywhere. Some fans got up and started booing, and Philly finally broke out of it to grab lead jam, but the prevalence of the stalemate start pervaded the oft-exciting, oft-frustrating tournament.

I found myself in the middle of a Twitter conversation on the tactic, an ongoing discussion that often invokes the disgust of skaters, refs and fans alike. To see two talented teams stand around behind the start line for a minute is good strategy for the team that’s ahead and in control of the bout — but it’s not very fan friendly.

I haven’t really had an issue with teams taking knees or making other tactical maneuvers to frustrate the opposing jammer and force the other team to counter because, in large part, they lead to a no-pack situation that allows the jammer an opportunity to break through and the game moves on. Strategies that lead to long bouts of non-action are less welcome.

With the success of the Gotham, other leagues will follow suit bringing the sport to a crawl … unless the ruling body Women’s Flat-Track Derby Association does something about it. Skater/ref Hannah Grenade observed that she has seen games with the LA Derby Dolls where the jammers are just sent anyway. And as the Wreckin Roller Rebels of Denver noted, the sport of roller derby is still so new that teams are finding ways around the current rules, so those running the sport will also learn to adapt.

Maybe so. But while teams like Gotham can win bouts with this tactic, the more important reaction was not how Philly countered, but the fans’ response. If we create a sport that bores fans, causes them to boo stall tactics and makes them not want to return to roller derby events, that means more than anything else. Sure, teams can win with a strategy that takes the excitement out of a sport … but if we alienate fans in the process, we all lose.

UPDATE: Both Oz coach Flyin Phil (in the comments) and Ithaca’s SufferJets (via Twitter) noted that WindyMan has an outstanding, detailed blog entry on this that includes a potential solution. Well worth reading!

2 responses to “are stalemate starts a blight on roller derby?

  1. Professor, I must wholeheartedly agree! There are a number of aspects of the current roller derby which easily confuse and alienate derby fans. In my opinion, the concept of rewarding a team for going slowly (or not at all in the case of a stalemate) has been an ongoing flaw in the WFTDA rules. I have heard many proposals for how to fix this, and most of the solutions seem to be fixing a symptom of the problem and not the cause. I must agree with WindyMan in his declaration that the cause of these problems is the pack definition itself. And he has a GREAT SOLUTION to the problem… if no pack exists, declare the front group of skaters as the pack, thereby rewarding skating forward and removing the advantage received from skating slowly. His write-up of the problem, along with his GREAT SOLUTION, is presented at http://windymanrd.wordpress.com/2011/09/13/the-pack-solution/ . I hope someone from WFTDA reads it and considers fixing the problem instead of just fixing symptoms.

  2. The rules of roller derby are decided by the skaters. The WFTDA rules are voted on by the WFTDA member leagues. In the past, the WFTDA member leagues typically have not changed the rules in the middle of their tournament season.

    Rules changes (roller derby and elsewhere) often have unintended consequences. The only guarantee about any proposal is that it’s not going to anticipate all of them.

    Full disclosure and disclaimer: I am an official affiliated with a WFTDA member league. I do not speak for that league or the WFTDA.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s